Optimal Decision-Making Styles To Drive Your Team To Success

Photo of author

By Jacob Maslow

When you’re leading a team, making decisions is one of the most important jobs a leader does. You will find yourself in a position where you must quickly decide on topics of high importance.

Any good leader will recognize that decision-making styles will work better in some situations than others, which will vary depending on the context, resources available, and team members’ preferences.

It’s important to know which decision-making style will be most effective for your particular situation and help drive your team to success.

So what are the four different decision-making styles?

Analytical Decision-Making Style

When it comes to making decisions, people can take many different approaches. Some people prefer to act on gut instinct, while others like to weigh all the options before concluding.

However, the decision-making process is usually a bit more systematic for those who prefer an analytical approach.

Analytical decision-makers tend to break down a problem into its parts to understand it better.

They will often ask questions to identify potential risks or pitfalls associated with a particular course of action. And once they have gathered all the relevant information, they will evaluate each option’s pros and cons before arriving at a final decision.

This systematic approach can take longer than other methods but often results in more well-thought-out decisions.

This decision-making process might be more favored when dealing with complex problems or situations that require careful consideration.

Example of Analytic Decision Making

An example of an analytic decision-making style would be in a situation such as investing in a new project.

The analytical decision-maker would break down all the costs associated with the project, review potential risks and benefits, compare it to other potential investments, and only then conclude whether it’s worth investing in.

Behavioral Decision-Making Style

Behavioral decision-makers tend to be more intuitive and spontaneous than their rational counterparts.

They are less likely to consider all of their options carefully and weigh the pros and cons before deciding. Instead, they are more likely to go with their gut feeling or follow their emotions.

Leaders who usually take a behavioral decision-making process are persuasive and good at communicating their vision and inspiring others.

This decision-making style might be more effective when there is a need for quick decisions or when dealing with highly motivated teams to see results.

Example of Behavioral Decision Making

An example of a behavioral decision-making style might be deciding whether to move to a new city for work.

A person using this decision-making process might look at their past experiences living in different places, what their friends and family think about the idea, and their feelings about the place before deciding whether to take the plunge and move.

This decision-making style relies heavily on personal experience and preferences, so it can be especially beneficial when making decisions that require a ‘gut feeling’ or an emotional attachment.

Conceptual Decision-Making Style

The third process of decision-making is known as conceptual decision-making.

This decision-making style involves taking a step back and looking at the big picture. Rather than getting bogged down in the details, conceptual decision-makers try understanding the underlying concepts and principles.

This allows them to make decisions based on a deep understanding of the situation.

While this approach can be practical, it is essential to remember that it is not always possible to see the big picture.

In some cases, details matter just as much as concepts. As such, it is crucial to use the right decision-making style for the situation.

Leaders who adopt this conceptual style of decision-making tend to be more willing to take risks and push boundaries to achieve their goals.

Example of Conceptual Decision Making

An example of a conceptual decision-making style might be deciding whether to invest in new technology.

The leader using this approach would look at the big picture and ask questions such as

  • How can this technology help us scale our business?
  • What are the long-term implications of investing in this technology?
  • How would it impact our industry?

By looking at the problem from a macro perspective, they can ensure that their decisions are well-thought-out and strategic.

Directive Decision-Making Style

A directive decision-making style is one in which the leader provides clear guidance and expectations to group members. This style is often used in situations where time is limited or there is a need for a quick decision.

In addition, this style can be effective when there is a clear understanding of the goal and a known path to achieving it.

However, a directive style can also lead to problems if used excessively or without regard for the input of others. Group members may feel that their ideas are not valued, leading to frustration and a loss of motivation.

In addition, this style can create an overly-hierarchical environment that stifles creativity and innovation.

As with any decision-making style, it is essential to use a directive approach only when appropriate and be aware of its potential drawbacks.

Example of Directive Decision Making

An example of a directive decision-making style might be deciding when to launch a new product.

The leader using this approach would provide clear instructions and a timeline for the project, including deadlines for tasks and milestones. This allows them to control the process while ensuring everyone is on track to meet their objectives.

At the same time, it is crucial to ensure that all team members feel valued and encouraged to contribute their ideas. This will help foster collaboration and ownership in the project, which can benefit productivity and morale.

Why It Is Important to Adopt Different Decision-Making Styles

When making decisions, it is essential to remember that there is no ‘one size fits all’ approach. Different situations require different decision-making styles and understanding which style can be the key to success.

Group decision-making can also be an effective way for leaders to make decisions. Including the input and ideas of multiple people can help ensure that all perspectives are considered and that the final judgment considers the collective wisdom of the group.

The best leaders can often combine different styles and adapt them to fit the situation.

This allows them to make effective decisions quickly while also considering the opinions of their team members and staying in control of the process.

Adopting this approach can help ensure that decisions are made with confidence and accuracy, no matter what challenges may arise.

It is an essential skill for any leader to have and one that can make a lasting impact on the success of their organization.

Summary: Understanding & Adopting the Correct Decision-Making Styles

Every leader wants to steer their team in the right direction, but making decisions can be tricky. Understanding different decision-making styles and using them appropriately in each situation is essential.

Being able to adapt and change styles depending on the situation is a vital skill for any leader to have.

Ultimately, understanding the different styles and adopting the correct one for each scenario can be the key to making effective decisions quickly and confidently. It is an invaluable skill that can help leaders unlock their team’s full potential.


What are the 4 decision-making styles?

The four decision-making styles are Analytical, Conceptual, Directive, and Behavioral.

What is the best style in decision-making?

The best style of decision-making depends on the situation. Adapting and changing styles depending on the context is essential to make effective decisions quickly and confidently.

What is analytical decision-making?

Analytical decision-making is a style in which decisions are based on facts and data rather than intuition or gut feeling. This style can be helpful when making complex decisions as it helps ensure that all the relevant information is considered.

Why are decision-making styles essential?

Decision-making styles are essential as they allow leaders to make effective decisions quickly and confidently, no matter what challenges may arise. Understanding different decision-making styles can help leaders unlock their team’s full potential.

Images Courtesy of DepositPhotos